Skip to main content
Home2012 Articles2011 Articles2010 Articles2009 Articles2008 Articles2007 Articles
 2009 Articles 
Sunday, November 29 2009

When Representative Joe Donnelly was elected to Congress in 2006, he joined the fictitious club of supposedly conservative Democrats called the "Blue Dogs."  By betraying constituents with his recent embrace of Nancy Pelosi's healthcare takeover, Joe Donnelly has proven himself not a blue dog, but a lap dog.


When Donnelly conducted a town hall meeting in Kokomo last August, he heard from a host of citizens angry about the irresponsible behemoth of a bill that Congressional Democrats had put together.  Despite misleading media reports coming from papers like the Kokomo Tribune that suggested the crowd was "evenly divided" on the issue, over 80% of the comments directed at Donnelly were skeptical and condemning of the Democrats' plan to interject more government into our healthcare system. 


Perhaps surprised by the crowd's hostility towards turning over their freedom to him and his fellow elites in Washington, Donnelly put on his "conservative Hoosier hat" for the evening, promising his constituents he: 1. would read the entire bill before voting, 2. would not vote to add to the deficit (odd, since he had just voted in favor of Obama's pork-laden, deficit-exploding, economy-depressing "stimulus" bill), 3. preferred government stay out of healthcare, and 4. wanted to clean up Medicare first.


Call me a cynic, but I didn't believe a word of it then.  Sometimes I hate being right.


This isn't to suggest that Congressman Donnelly was in an easy spot.  The leaders of his party had put him in a position where he had to choose between losing the support of his party bosses like Pelosi and Obama (and thus the money they would send his way for a re-election campaign), or betraying his constituents by going back on his word.  It was a test of character for Donnelly.  A test he failed.


On his website, Donnelly boasts of himself that, "It has never been about Democrats or Republicans. It's about doing what is right for families here in Indiana and across the country."  Yet when it mattered most, Donnelly proved those to be empty words.  They are the hollow ramblings of just another Washington politician whose primary objective is preserving his own power, even if it means throwing those "families here in Indiana" under the socialized medicine bus.


Donnelly's critical vote allowed a bill to pass that is blatantly unconstitutional.  Democrats, including Donnelly, have not yet been able to explain where Congress gets the authority to force Americans to purchase health insurance.  This is not like auto insurance.  If you choose not to drive, you don't have to purchase auto insurance.  If this healthcare plan goes through, Joe and his compatriots will have left you the following options: buy it, die, or go to jail. 


Thanks to Donnelly's sell-out, we are one step closer to a bill that will slash Medicare spending (section 1161), put the government in charge of approving all health insurance plans (section 224), hammer small businesses with fines for not obeying orders (section 412), cut reimbursement rates for doctors (section 1158), and cause the tax burden on middle class Americans to skyrocket.


This is why when Donnelly brags about having read the entire bill, I actually hope he is lying.  Because if he did read this monstrosity and still voted for it, the degree of his lapdog status becomes even more glaring.


So how does Donnelly explain this outrageous betrayal?  He doesn't.  I've been waiting to ask the Congressman myself, but after setting up a monthly interview with me on my radio program two years ago, Donnelly has participated in just one, earning him the moniker "Silent Joe."  He is apparently more content to talk with media outlets that aren't interested in holding him accountable for his votes.


And evidently Congressman Donnelly has adopted a new policy for interaction with his in and out of the district in secret appearances before anyone catches wind that he's in town.  It is reminiscent of the way the president will fly into a war zone to visit the troops unexpectedly, and then leave before the enemy has a chance to gather.  A word of advice to Mr. Donnelly: when you're having to make stealth appearances in the district you supposedly represent, that should tell you something about how well you're doing your job.


Then again, after reading Donnelly's response to a senior citizen who questioned his vote, this strategy of avoiding his constituents might be wise.  He attempted to pacify her concerns by stating, "I [say], turn off the TV and listen to a Frank Sinatra record."  And there you have it...a perfect indictment of Donnelly as a bona fide member of the inner-Washington crowd sending us peons the message: "Don't you people worry about paying attention to what I'm doing and what I'm voting in favor of...just listen to your records and let me run your life for you.  Just trust me."


Silent Joe must go.

Posted by: Peter Heck AT 02:38 pm   |  Permalink   |  4 Comments  |  Email
It's sad that so many of our Democratic congressmen are more interested in pleasing Nancy Pelosi than in pleasing their constituents. Why is that? Pelosi can't vote them out of office next year. We can. I guess most of them feel safe in their gerrymandered districts and think the tea parties, town hall protests, and the 8 million pink slips they're swimming in are just so much bluster.
Posted by Down with Liberalism on 12/01/2009 13:39:30
It's sad that so many of our Republican congressman are more interested in pleasing Tea Party fanatics than pleasing their constituents. Why is that? Voters can't vote them out til next year. I guess most of them feel safe in their gerrymandered districts (ie Dan Burton) and think that the the the 2008 election results and and the 8 year war that War Lord Bush got us in swimming in our young peoples blood is just so much bluster. Oh and now Palin goes birther. You and "I release mass murderers" Huckabee go ahead and run in 2012. I can wait.
Posted by Down with Conservatism on 12/04/2009 23:55:06
Donnell's vote came to me as a unwelcome surprise, he stated he would not vote for it and I took him at his word.. If he would have remained firm with his commitment to vote no. I would have gladly voted again for him. But he has decided that his party is more important than the popular opinion of his constituents.. Every body I knows agrees for the most part that the health care system needs reformed. I'm voting anybody but Donnelly. Donnelly blatantly lied to us and I want to show him it's his constituents that signs his paycheck not anybody in congress or higher. Perhaps the state of Indiana needs to consider joining Virginia. I hope we do...
Posted by Betrayed citizen on 03/22/2010 15:00:07
Do you suppose it even dawned on Mr. "Down with Conservatism" poster that the Democrats drew the district lines for Dan Burton. Are we to then conclude, Mr. Genius, that the Democrats gerrymandered the districts for a Republican? Sheesh. Sometimes left wing stupidity is breathtaking.
Posted by GD on 03/26/2010 20:13:49

Post comment
Email Address

(max 750 characters)
* Required Fields
Note: All comments are subject to approval. Your comment will not appear until it has been approved.

    common sense makes a comeback
    site designed by Keith Parker   --  sign up for Peter Heck Mailing List here